[Critiques spectateurs]

[Guigui]

Ces messages ont été supprimés temporairement suite à une demande de la FOX afin de ne pas révéler des éléments de l'histoire pour préserver le plaisir des spectateurs. Le film étant sorti aujourd'hui aux USA, je pense qu'on peut au moins réouvrir ce topic pour y lire les reviews des "vrais gens". Pour le topic sur les critiques presse il faudra attendre demain par contre...

Aujourd'hui on va en avoir des reviews

[Guigui]

La première review d'un fan francophone qui n'est pas un critique est dispo sur EPIDERMIQ' : http://www.epidermiq.com/forums/viewtop ... &start=440

et attention c'est super mauvais !!! Pourtant ce même fan n'est autre que le webmaster de X-FILES ULTIMATE, alors c'est dire... Je pense pas que lui on pourra pas l'accuser de quoi que ce soit à part d'être un fan déçu lourdement !

[mudly]

Comment gâcher une journée... On s'en doutait un peu depuis quelques temps, mais là c'est vrai, c'est sur...Bon j'irais le voir quand même, pour me faire ma propre idée, mais mon cœur sera lourd... On peut faire une croix ( X ..!!!) sur un 3... Remarquez si c'est pour une autre bouse...


Dur, Dur d'être X-Phile...

[Guigui]

Moi aussi je vais le voir bien sûr, en avant première mardi... Je garde toujours l'espoir fou que tout ceci n'est qu'un énorme HOAX

[usb2]

Une critique positive sur Allociné :

[spoiler]Je suis actuellement a Prague ou le film est sorti aujourd hui. Ni une, ni deux, je me suis empresse d aller le voir.

Tout d abbord je tien a preciser que je ne suis pas un fan de X files, juste un cinephile chevronne amateur de fantastique et qui a aime les quelques episodes qu il a vu. Mais je n ai jamais ete au dela de la saison 1.

Alors voila ma critique sans spoiler:

Le film demarre vite, contrairement a beaucoup du meme genre, et sa fait plaisir. Il tient plus du film independant a petit budget qu au blockbuster, contrairement au premier film. Alors c est une question de gout, moi personnellement j ai beaucoup aime cette ambiance riviere pourpre/silence des agneaux.
Les protagonistes sont tres credibles et meme si le combat entre les rationnels et les > est toujours la, on appreciera qu ils n aient pas base le film la dessus. Le film est base plutot sur le combat interieur des personnages, jusqu ou est on pret a aller pour faire ce qui nous semble juste?
Ainsi l enquete de Mulder et Scully n a pas grand chose de personnelle en apparence, mais elle fait ressortir leurs demons interieurs pour un film psychologique.

Voyez le comme un film policier. L histoire est tres bonne, c etait en anglais sans sous titre alors meme si je maitrise cette langue je ne peux pas vous garantire qu il n y a pas un truc qui m ait echape. Mais les rebondissements et le suspens sont au rendez vous.

On regrettera une chose, les courses poursuites illisibles, meme si ce n est pas un film d action. Ici encore c est une question de gout, sa donne un style au film. Sa ne m a pas derange plus que sa d autant que le suspens est present.

Voila, en esperant vous avoir eclaire, si vous avez des questions n hesitez pas[/spoiler]

Source : http://www.allocine.fr/communaute/forum ... 31886.html

[calicalou]

J'essaye de me rassurer comme je peux.

J'analyse la chose ainsi, (ne me lyncher pas siouplé !!! )

Peut-être que nous FANS de la série, attendons tellement de ce film (et ce qu'il représente pour la communauté internationale X-Philienne), que nous ne pouvons que ressortir déçus de la salle de cinéma.
Déçus par rapport à des attentes que chacun de nous avions basées sur notre ressenti de la série.
Pour certains, le noirceur des histoires, pour d'autres les sujets paranormaux, pour d'autres encore une liaison amoureuse M/S, et encore plein d'autres choses.
Chacun de nous aime X-Files pour quelques choses de bien précis...

Je pense que nous sommes les juges les plus sévères pour le film.

Sans ressenti aucun, je pense que les novices accrocheront par l'histoire même du Thriller.
Ce qui va les amener à une découverte de la série et de ses 9 saisons ou 202 épisodes, ou encore 59 DVD (je compte pas les heures, ni les minutes ....).

Personnellement, je prends ce film comme un cadeau (il y à pas si longtemps, nous étions entrain de faire une pétition d'enfer afin qu'il voit le jour...) et même si il n'est pas à la hauteur, je serais contente d'avoir vu nos deux agents dans une enquête nouvelle...

C'était juste un petit ressenti de tous ce que nous entendons depuis quelques jours.

[Guigui]

Y a sans doute du vrai dans ce que tu dis

[Guigui]

Une bonne review positive...

[spoiler]by elessar on Fri Jul 25, 2008 5:14 am from XFU forum

Okay, I've seen it three times already and I have also read the reviews from some of you ( ) as well as those who were expecting God knows what......(stupid critics) and here is mine (not that spoiler-y)

The X-Files “I Want to Believe”, is Chris Carter’s most personal and most mature X-File ever. Carter set out to make a film that would stand on its own, and in that he succeeds. He set out to make a story for the non-fans and he succeeds in doing so as well. Perhaps some who are unfamiliar with Mulder and Scully, if that is possible, will find it hard to follow the depth of their relationship but for those who know even a little something will enter a world where two people live, breath, behave like every single person out there and struggle to understand the meaning of it all while the same time being in a complex, mature and loving relationship.
“I Want to Believe”, is exactly what Carter and Frank Spotnitz, as well as Gillian and David said it would be. A stand alone thriller that goes back to the scary stories the show presented the fans with during its first four years on TV. What they forgot to mention was that you have got to be a die hard fan to understand the lack of dialogue and interpret the looks between the main characters if you want to understand what’s going on between them. What they also forgot to tell us is that there is a complex scary story in the heart of the film, a theory that is plausible but still only a theory, taken out there and stretched in the usual way the X-Files used to stretch theories, adding a little bit of writing magic and dazzling us with the science of the “what if” question, and finally, what they all omitted to add was that you have to be familiar with the “ship” in order to leave the theater in the end with the biggest grin on your face ever (sorry I couldn’t resist).
Now, taking things and breaking them down, scene by scene, cut by cut, the movie delivers. It delivers as a movie ought to that doesn’t involve a mature grown up man in tights, or a psychologically disable man who dresses up as a bat and jumps around buildings or a whatever superhero studio execs throw at us every year to collect dough on the Box Office. This movie delivers because Carter and Spotnitz did what they do best. They based it not only on a scary plot but on a real relationship and on real people who hurt, cry, scream, feel the pain and the agony, and want to live far away from the darkness. The movie delivers indeed, even for those who are not obsessed with the X. There’s snow, that’s true, a lot of snow, lots and lots of snow. It seems that the world is covered with it, period. There’s action, there’s eerie movie, there’s scary jumping out of your seat stuff, there are things and issues and events that concern the world these days, all intertwined in the case and the dialogues, always written in the wittiest way (Carter is the best when it comes to hints and cynicism). There are squeamish things that make you want to look away, medical things and science based issues, issues of faith, like there has always been in the X-Files. Issue of faith versus science as well as how far science can go without breaking issues of moral. This and much more in 1 hour and 55 minutes, credits included.
However, the heart, the soul, the reason why this movie was ever made is one and one alone. It was made for the fans and it was made because of Mulder and Scully. From the moment we first gaze at Dr. Scully’s back to the final moment after the end credits roll, there is Mulder and Scully, even if only one of them is on screen. It is exactly what Duchovny said, yes, two people who are trying to make it work while working, and that there is a lot of work in that, but, the heart of this movie is what these two people share. Don’t get me wrong here folks, this is a drama, suspense thriller but Carter and Frank perhaps manage to create a new genre that stands on its own. A love story, romantic supernatural drama, suspense thriller, and perhaps the only one in the genre ‘cause frankly I don’t see how someone else can copy that.
Yes some might find the sexual resolved tension a little bit cheesy, but it is presented in the most intelligent and heart felt manner. Yes some might think that they only wanted the story and the spookiness instead of the kiss and the love. However, the people who want all that are obviously in the wrong movie.
This IS the X-Files folks, and it is as great and as personal as it has never been. The relationship of Mulder and Scully IS what the X-Files is, was and will always be about. Forget the psychics or the Flukeman or the Aliens, this, two people, in love, trying hard to fight the darkness, embrace the loss, move on, work their relationship, life and job, make it work, be together, worry for each other, share they things they do and NEVER, EVER GIVE UP, but even in the harshest of times, still fight the fight, this IS what the show and the movie, this movie is all about.
Gillian might seem off at some points but her Scully IS the most real heroine I have ever seen with such a deep background and she has matured so beautifully both on the outside and the inside. The look on her face when dealing with Christian’s case is the look that made me feel like chocking and hold my breath when that weight on my chest and throat felt like tons and tons of steel pushing down every time she held back her tears and her eyes turned red with support and love for the boy. Carter and Frank know how to write Scully when it comes to kid’s who suffer and boy does Gillian know how to play her!
David finally gives his Mulder the maturity and the growth that we all wanted and hoped and prayed! Mulder is the one saying that he is only part of the team, acknowledging finally that it is them and not just him! Mulder is the one who refuses to personalize, Mulder never gave up and Mulder becomes the tree that Scully needs to lean on and draw strength. He made me cry, he really did.
The story becomes a little too complex, the F.B.I. indeed needs Mulder and Scully but not for the case per se but in order to become a little loose ‘cause it feels that they have been so stiff and so tight and anal that they actually need someone whose theories are out there to loosen them up a little. Drummy is good, for a rapper turned actor, Peet gazes at Mulder and makes Scully jealous, but soon ends up down an elevator shaft, ouch, in a way that only the Fowl one deserved to and then she is not even mentioned. It is, however, Skinner’s short appearance that strikes for the nostalgia and makes you want to scream when you see him on the big screen. His presence and final scene is what made me cry again, the bond he has with these people and how well he knows them.
In the end you wait to be blown away, to go out with a bang, but it is not an X-File way to end things or wrap it up, it’s only the hope and the smiles and the words and the “what if” and the “what’s next” that the X-Files fans have loved and learned to appreciate when it comes to end and wrapping up a story. In the end it’s Mulder’s words that made you cry your heart out, it is Scully’s decision NOT to give up and to HAVE faith in herself and it’s the final moment, a wink towards the fans, them together like that, maybe off character but oh the much needed comfort and the farewell we craved for years, a goodbye from Frank, Carter, Duchovny and Anderson to the fans, if this ends up being the last X-File ever.
Yes, perhaps it might, but even if it does, even if we never see what happens in 2012 and we never learn what happened to William or to the rest of the Scooby’s I wouldn’t care personally because this is how I want to remember them. Happy, together, in the deep blue endless sea, alone, the two of them, out of the darkness and into the light, because let’s face it, the X-Files always has been about hope and about seeing and finding the light even when the world was falling apart. The gang, our gang has always been our constant, our touchstone and for yet another (the 203rd) X-File, the sure NAILED it![/spoiler]

[Spooky.]

merci de ne pas mettre des critiques de presse dans cette section, ici ce sont les critiques spectateurs et non de presse.

[Guigui]

merci de ne pas mettre des critiques de presse dans cette section, ici ce sont les critiques spectateurs et non de presse.

Yep, le topic presse sera réouvert ce soir à minuit lorsque l'embargo sera levé. Ton post y sera Yanis
Merci de votre compréhension...

[Guigui]

La première review d'un fan francophone qui n'est pas un critique est dispo sur EPIDERMIQ' : http://www.epidermiq.com/forums/viewtop ... &start=440

et attention c'est super mauvais !!! Pourtant ce même fan n'est autre que le webmaster de X-FILES ULTIMATE, alors c'est dire... Je pense pas que lui on pourra pas l'accuser de quoi que ce soit à part d'être un fan déçu lourdement !

Voici ce qu'il a posté comme review sur XFU :

[spoiler]My sad but quick review
by Webmaster on Fri Jul 25, 2008 9:20 am

Hi guys! I'm finally back checking XFU! Thanks for all the e-mails you sent me, it took me like 20 minutes to read everything!

So, time has come for a review. I've got so much to say! I will first do a small review and will update it many times, until I post it on XFU. It'll take me a while, since I really want to do it properly and leave nothing behind.

If some of you get offended while reading negative comments about The X-Files, just don't read it.

WARNING, THIS CONTAINS HUGE SPOILERS

Let's cut to the chase here: this movie is awfully bad. I've never seen a movie that bad in years.
The story
First, the plot. The story makes no sense at all and is really dumb. At the end, I thought: "So?".
We've waited so long to see a kidnapping story. And the paranormal element is also very dumb. When Scully is doing researches on Stem-cell research, I just felt very bad for her...

Scary movie
The light was pretty cool, but there was no atmosphere at all during the all film. For months, Chris Carter kept saying "This is a good-old scary movie." Well, I was far more scared during the previews just before the movie than during the 1h40 of TXF2. The only moments that should have been scary are so badly done that it wasn't scary at all. On the contrary, it felt very disturbing, in a pathetic way.

Disturbing
And yes, this film felt very disturbing. For instance, the George W. Joke was simply out of context. We're talking about art, here. Not some random popcorn movie with lame jokes inside of it.
Remember the first seasons? Just compare any episodes from the first 6 seasons with this one... You get the point.
Then, the theology aspect of the movie is just completely bad and also wrong. And I won't say that I found the movie homophobic, but that aspect of the film was also totally dumb.
Seriously, this movie tries to do everything and in the end does nothing at all.

Gillian/David
There was one good aspect though. Gillian Anderson is an amazingly talented actress and gives a very good and really intelligent performance. David Duchovny was also very good. They were still Mulder and Scully and that praised chemistry was still there.
Then, I've never liked the acting of Amanda Peet, and this movie isn't an exception.

Billy Connolly
Connolly is a great actor, but not in I Want to Believe. I don't think it's his fault though. His lines were so bad that he had almost no material at all to help him.

For the fans
What does "for the fans" means? If that means throwing plenty of dull references, well, Chris and Frank succeeded it. The is the ninth season syndrom all over again. And I'm afraid to say that, but season 9 was really good, compared to that film. It was as if Chris was thinking "let's putting them into bed and the fans will like it..."

The music
I have nothing to say about the music. There were a few good seconds there, but that was it. Suddenly, I heard a theme from Fight the Future, and I just felt bad because that was a great film! Indeed, when I first saw "Fight the Future" in 1998, I left the movie theater being really exstatic. FTF was PURE GOLD, compared to this one.

In the end, Chris Carter had everything in his hands. A nice budget (yes, 35 millions is really enough), some great actors (Gillian, David, Billy Connolly), the amazing landscapes from Pemberton, and... six years to think about it. I have the feeling that Chris did nothing for 5 years and then wrote a script really quickly because of the WGA strike. This is a shame. And I don't see how this movie will succeed on the box-office.
And I am so disappointed, because Mulder and Scully were back! Duchovny and Anderson were so good together! There were sparks when they were together and it felt so good to see them again. But their characters were just thrown into the emptiness of a very bad script.

So, I just got three minutes left. Time to give it a note... And I'm very sad to say this, but the note I give it is 1 out of 5.

(I got plenty of things to say, so I'll come back later, ++)[/spoiler]

[FX]

En voilà une autre très positive
Le gars est co-auteur de "The Complete X-Files," mais a posté en tant que simple spectateur.

[spoiler]All right, I just got back from a midnight showing and I am extremely agitated. First off, let me just say I am the co-author of The Complete X-Files, out in October, so I may have a bias. However, I made up my mind to not post about the movie if I didn't love it. It's not like anyone was waiting for my review or anything, so I have no reason to tell you people anything but the undiluted truth. That being said, I absolutely cannot believe some of the negative reviews out there. There is no doubt in my mind some of these critics made up their minds about the film before they even saw it.The X-Files doesn't fit into whatever passes for pop culture these days, so it's fair game for a drubbing. Watching the dreadful coming attractions- with pointless explosion after pointless computer effect, I thanked God that this film is a black sheep. This is an amazing film on its own. For X-Philes- especially 'Shippers, this is godhead. I can't tell you anything about the book since I signed a NDA, but I can tell all of you that Chris Carter is the most hardcore 'Shipper on the face of the planet. And you see the proof of that in this very rich emotional pudding. I'll come clean and tell you I wasn't a big fan of Fight the Future- to me The X-Files is about intimacy. This film is everything I wanted it to be- dark, unsettling, and extremely intimate. And believe me, there are plenty of suspenseful moments in this film, especially the chase scene on the construction site.

I kept waiting for all these scenes that were supposed to ruin it all, or for some gaffe that would take me out of the narrative, but it never came. The nitpicking didn't make me angry at the filmmakers, it made me angry at the nitpickers. What I saw on the screen was a dark, intense, bleaker-than-hell thriller that was no retread, but very much a progression in the spirit of the classic X-Files. The gritty cinematography and the washed-out palette do not look "cheap," they are used to tell the story of Mulder and Scully's lives and their sense of loss and disappointment. There are some amazing shots in this film- some amazing establishing shots and some chiaroscuro lighting effects that create an extremely creepy mood that will get under your skin.

I didn't get comped on my tickets, I paid for it myself and I'm doing so again tonight. And I'm looking forward to it. I was quite ready to be disappointed by this movie and all I am is disappointed in a pack of reviewers who dismiss something because it's no longer deemed to be hip. Go see this movie and be proud of your obsession.[/spoiler]

Le moins que l'on puisse dire est que les avis sont très tranchés dans un sens comme dans l'autre mais on est loin du consensus négatif que l'on avait au début.

Une seconde, toujours positive.

[spoiler]just got back,
i think this movie was great and a great way to end and leaves it open for more i honestly do not believe people understand what this is about, i went in with really low(because of the reviews) expectations and loved it,the characters where true and most of all it is about there relationship it really is a drama i think people expect the wrong thing with this film.
The few final scenes where great and really left on a great note and a funny one right at the end.If it ended like this i would not be disappointed, i think maybe knowing the show is what you need to love this,and i am not bias if a hated i would just say it.The x file is second to the meat of the story which is faith and what is actually important to the characters and if you notice at the end Mulder gives up his quest for the truth he is content with a life with Dana and that was the meat of the story.

I think people are looking at this movie totally the wrong way,it's a character driver piece not an x file one,the character's
are the x file.The ending was beautiful and well written i can see where there coming from but i honestly think some people want this to be a huge blockbuster when really it's just a small movie with a lot of love and heart
at the end i was waiting for Mulder to say just you and me a second before he said it maybe because i took my girlfriend
and i was thinking of her and then he said exactly the way i was thinking it was perfect and weird.
i was in a shit mood today and the last thing i wanted to do was watch a movie and by the end i was really happy
stuff the critics i honestly don't think they understand how it was all connected and how it all interplayed.
with the stem cell research and the church being two sides and Dana is using her powers as a doctor for the work of good
and the other doctors for the work of evil,it is all connected and well thought out.I think that just a lot of it went over everyones heads,but anyway that's my two cents i would give it about a eight out of ten and i think it was better then the first movie and i hope they make one more.

Russ from Aust.[/spoiler]

Histoire de rester dans le positif, en voici une troisième

[spoiler]Ok guys, it's hard for me to say this but I um... how should I put it... I freakin' LOVED it!!!
I was really worried about all those critics and shitty stuff, I was so nervous I almost got out before the movie even started. Serious panic attack moment there!!!
The very first scenes are great, they set a really new mood after season 9 (which I liked but, it was different you know), it's dark, cold, creepy and very x-filish! When I saw Scully and Mulder together, (eventhough the beard was funny in a weird way) for the very first time, I got chills. That's when I realised they were back!!! Scully's plot was better than Mulder's, mostly because he spent a lot of time with Amanda Peet (nothing personnal, I didn't really like her character, it was a bit Monicaesque in a much more annoying way) and being stubborn like in the past! GA is amazing, really! She made us cry in the series but in IWTB she really shines! She brought tears to my eyes twice! DD is fantastic as always. He is so Mulder even when he is not trying! I love how much the characters have changed. Mulder's line: 'I'm only part of the team' was priceless. I felt like hugging him. (He realised only now, what we have know for about 15 years LOL) Scully's 'That's why I fell in love with you' made my heart skip a beat! (eventhough I was spoiled like hell lol actually hearing her say it was AMAZING)
Their bond is stronger than ever and their chemistry -GOD- breathtaking!
The MSR here is just PERFECT really, so skilfully handled. Seasons' 8 & 9 doesn't even begin to compare!!
Every scene with M&S was GRANDIOSE. I loved, loved, loved, the bed scene and what comes next! No love scene ever made in film history is as remarkable as this one! It was so simple and ordinary and yet means so much!
Loved the book on Scully's nightstand (really evocative lol ) and their toxicology talk, so M&S :laugh1:
When they talked about William, I felt really sad. The pain is still so 'fresh'.
I really enjoyed the fight scene (I didn't get the impression they had really broken up) I don't know it allowed a certain amount of angst to fill the air, it was quite 'rousing'!
The rescue scene was once again handled amazing well! Instead of a soap operaish reunion we get a 'sorry about your car' from Mulder and the look on Scully's face.. ugh precious! The last scene was once again so tender and meaningful. And the kiss, a treat for the eyes!
The boat scene is the icing on the cake. I think it's both DD&GA and M&S, depends on how you choose to view it! It's was a nice ''love gesture'' from the writers and actors towards the characters, I believe! They allow them to find a little peace of Heaven in a world so cold and dark sometimes! And an homage to the SHIP...
The X-file now, well it certainly wasn't what I was expecting but it actually was good and satisfactorily concluded!
What I think interesting is the way the characters dominate the plot! The way they relate to the case and bring the story forward, as they question their own beliefs and fight that inner battle of theirs, caused by such a rich personnal history.
The plot/x-file is obviously secondary here (but still good and interesting). It's a means to an end. The main focus are these two people and how they relate to a fate they didn't chose! It's about the questions it raises and the struggle to find the answers.
The directing and low budget might be disturbing to some, to me it fits just right. They allow the movie to be darker and the characters to be the spotlight.
This is visibly a very personal, intimate, intellectual movie. Isn't what TXF is (also) about? Plus after all this time M&S deserve their moment. This is a great homage to them.
I really think this movie is brilliant. Some might disagree and use CGI arguments, pointless gunshots/explosions and multi-rewarded directers to try and discredit IWTB, but I still believe in TXF.

Side note: I think that what's hurting the movie is that people were expecting aliens and monsters, when this is a character-centered intellectual movie!
Go see it people. I went alone yesterday, I'm gonna go with a few friends this time around.[/spoiler]

Elles proviennent toutes d' X files ultimate

[T-1000]

C’est la première foix que je j’ose émettre une critique, donc soyez indulgent! PAS DE SPOILERS.

En gros le film m’a laissé un drôle d’impréssion, pas mauvais, mais j’ai eu l’impression tout le long du film d’être assis devant mon téléviseur à regarder un épisode sur DVD. Je crois que cette hitoire aurait gagné à être racourcie sur 45 minutes!

Il y a tout de même plusieurs choses positives, Duchovny est en forme, on sentait son plaisir à reprnendre le personnage de Mulder. Les images sont superbes. La mise en scêne est tres sobre, l’atmosphère X-Files est bien présente tout le long du film, on à même quelque surprises en ce qui conserne la relation Mulder/Scully. Je dirais qu’il y a un petit quelque chose du Silence des Agneaux ou de Seven dans ce film! Et même une première en ce qui me conserne, Mulder à réusis à me faire rire deux fois avec ces plaisenterie d’un goût douteux, ce n’est pas rien, j’ai toujours été imperméable à l’humour de Mulder! Tous les éléments étaient là pour un très bon film!

Mais malheureusement le scénario en lui-même, il avait les qualités pour faire un bon épisode de 45 minutes, pas un film de 1 heure 45. Je dis ça, et je vais être probablement déçu si le film sort en DVD avec la version régulière, et non avec des scènes rajoutées! :-) Pour finir, le film est déjà mieux selon moi, que se laissaient présager les premières critiques du début de semaine! Ceux qui n’ont pas une grande attente vis à vis du film vont probablement passer un bon moment!

Cordialement,

T-1000

[Guigui]

C’est la première foix que je j’ose émettre une critique, donc soyez indulgent! PAS DE SPOILERS.

Pas de soucis : ta critique était très bien, merci de tes impressions...
Moi j'ai acheté ma place pour mardi soir... J'ai plus qu'à me faire mon opinion

[Darky]

Bon, vu et j'ai trouvé ça carrément décevant.

La première partie, ça va mais la 2e accumule les pires défauts que s'en est pathétique et fait passer les dernières saisons dans leurs globalités pour de très bonne saisons et je ne plaisante pas. S'en est désolant de voir Chris Carter pondre un script aussi à chier alors qu'il a eu 6 ans pour l'écrire et que la série possède plusieurs stand-alones bien meilleurs que ce X-Files 2 qui c'est pas mal planté en ce qui me concerne.

3/10

[Spooky.]

j'ai eu l'occasion de le voir aussi...

Perso j'ai bien aimé, je ne dit pas adoré, j'ai plus été content de revoir nos acteurs sur grand écrans que l'histoire.... je trouve la traduction française pas terrible car j'ai eu l'impression ça alourdi le tout... j'espère pouvoir voir une version Anglaise sous titrée .. lol

sinon dans l'ensemble j'ai trouvé plutôt bien tout ça.

si je devrais donner une note je donnerais 8.5/10 , il est vrai que j'attendais quand même un peu plus.. mais bon ça étais mieux que rien ! ce qui m'as le plus réjoui c'est de pouvoir voir nos acteurs préféré sur grand écran !


je retourne le voir mardi, je vais essayé de me concentré plus sur le film et sur l'histoire cette fois ci

[langly]

La chance vous l'avez vus **bave**

[Clairette]

Ohlala ça fait peur tout ça... hâte d'être mardi pour trancher moi-même...

[Lisa]

Même reaction de certaines connaissances qui l'ont vu également. L'impression de voir un épisode de la série et non un film. Il pourrai s'integrer sans problème dans une saison.

Beaucoup de déception.

[Camerata]

Apparemment, les avis sont très partagés, soit on adore soit on n'aime vraiment pas